Go directly to these sections:

    The time and effort expended on optimizing the growth conditions of recombinant organisms is amply rewarded with convenient fermentation and high yield of recombinant protein. After the expression system has been determined, and the preferred growth medium selected, it is critical to craft a set of conditions that results in low stress and high productivity.

    It's not surprising: combine agitation with surfactant and you get ... foam.

    In any suspension culture — whether your protein expression host is bacterial, yeast, insect, or mammalian — the growth medium needs to be agitated to aerate and suspend the cells. And many culture media contain proteins and other components with surfactant properties. Whenever these two conditions are met, foam is an almost inescapable complication.

    Why should you care about foam? There are several good reasons:

    • A head of foam seriously inhibits gas exchange at the surface, sickening the culture, especially as the cell density rises.
    • If your expression system is designed for extracellular fusion protein production, the product is being sent into a hazardous environment; foam is notorious for denaturing proteins in solution.
    • Finally, foam is just plain messy. It gets in the way of decanting, filtration, centrifugation — almost any fluid-handling operation you'll perform as you begin to isolate the product from your culture.

    What to do?

    Antifoams

    Admittedly, this isn't rocket science. Truth be told, it's rather a low-tech answer to your high-tech problem. But it is an answer; it works; and it has the virtue of simplicity.

    What's an antifoam?Antifoams have been used in foodstuffs, pharmaceuticals, and manufacturing processes for many years. They are silicone-based polymers, non-silicone organics, or mixtures of both. They work at very low concentrations to suppress foaming in aqueous media, typically in the range of 0.005 – 0.02%.

    Here are a few things you should know when using antifoams in cell culture systems:

    • If you intend to harvest cells using microfiltration or to concentrate extracellular protein with ultrafiltration, you should try to select a non-silicone antifoam. Silicones tend to foul the membranes used in these procedures.
    • Microbes may actually adapt to use some antifoams as growth substrates. If so, the expression pattern of the bug can be affected, and expression of the desired recombinant protein may be reduced. Another concern: if the antifoam is metabolized, it can't continue to suppress foaming.
    • It is possible for certain types of antifoams to inhibit the growth of the culture. You'll want to insure that the culture grows up to nearly the same final cell density with the antifoam as without it.
    • Naturally, you'll want to add only sterile components to your fermentation. Choose an antifoam that can be sterilized without degradation.
    • For controlling foam in large-scale fermenters, you'll want an antifoam that can be delivered by pump on an as-needed basis. Some are too viscous or heterogeneous for pumping. The addition can be automated if the pump is controlled by a foam probe in the fermentation vessel.

    It's as simple as that. Sigma's antifoams (see Table 1) all have been tested with E. coli (ATCC #25922) and B. subtilis (ATCC #6051) in Terrific Broth. In all cases, the final OD600 in cultures with the antifoam is at least 80% of the value without it. We're in the process of extending testing to other expression systems and other media. If you check back here, on our Web site, you'll be among the first to know.

    Table 1: Which Antifoam is Right for Your Needs?
    Product Number Antifoam Autoclave? Pump? Typical Concentration Chemistry
    A 6207 Antifoam 204 Yes Yes 0.005 – 0.01% non-silicone organic in polyol dispersion
    A 6332 Antifoam 289 Yes Yes 0.005 – 0.01% silicone/non-silicone mix in polyol dispersion
    A 6582 Antifoam A Concentrate Yes No 0.005 – 0.01% 100% silicone
    A 6457 Antifoam A Emulsion Yes Yes 0.005 – 0.01% 30% emulsion of Antifoam A Concentrate with non-ionic emulsifiers
    A 6707 Antifoam B Emulsion Yes Yes 0.01 – 0.02% 10% emulsion of Antifoam A Concentrate with non-ionic emulsifiers
    A 6832 Antifoam C Emulsion Yes Yes 0.005 – 0.01% 30% emulsion of Antifoam A Concentrate with non-ionic emulsifiers
    A 8207 Antifoam O-10 Yes Yes 0.01 – 0.02% 100% organic; water-dispersible
    A 8082 Antifoam O-30 Yes Yes 0.01 – 0.02% 100% organic (fatty ester); water dispersible
    A 7957 Antifoam O-60 Yes Yes 0.01 – 0.02% 100% organic; not water dispersible but soluble in oils or alcohol
    A 8582 Antifoam SE-15 Yes Yes 0.01 – 0.02% 10% silicone in non-ionic emulsifier; water-dispersible
    A 8707 Antifoam SE-35 Yes Yes 0.01 – 0.02%
    A 7207 Antifoam SO-25 Yes If pre- dispersed 0.005 – 0.01% silicone in polyol dispersion; water-dispersible
    Keeping it Clean: A New Approach to Preparing Microbial Media with EZMix™

    While we're on the subject of components for efficient growth of recombinant organisms, let's take a look at media.

    For the best results, you must provide a rich, complete growth medium.This usually involves a standard-recipe broth with or without specific supplementation to meet the nutritional requirements of the expression host. Though it is one of the most fundamental techniques in microbiology, media prep can go awry.

    Cleanliness is key. Contamination, wasted time and materials, and confused results are all but inevitable without it. Yet most microbial media components are dusty, sticky powders — hard to pour, hard to weigh, hard to dissolve — making it that much more challenging to meet the cleanliness commitment.

    We'd like to propose a solution. At Sigma, we developed a proprietary process that converts standard microbial media components into EZMix™ free-flowing, non-dusting, dense, wettable powders. Each EZMix powder has the same growth characteristics as the untreated powder, with clear advantages in handling and dissolution.

    These EZMix media and media components are the first in a growing family. Though the EZMix process is a benign one, we take nothing for granted. Each new formulation is tested before release so you can be assured that it will perform as expected. If your favored medium is not yet on this list or if you have some comments about your experiences with EZMix powders, drop us an e-mail. We want to hear from you.

    Table 2: Non-dusting EZMix Products
    EZMix Media
    L 7533 EZMix LB Agar 6 x 500 ml
    1 kg
    L 7658 EZMix LB Broth Base 6 x 500 ml
    2 x 5 liters
    1 kg
    N 6905
    NEW
    EZMix NZCYM Broth 6 x1 liter
    250 g
    1 kg
    T 9179 EZMix Terrific Broth 6 x 500 ml
    2 x 5 liters
    1 kg
    EZMix Media Components
    C 4464
    NEW
    EZMix N-Z-Amine 250 g
    500 g
    1 kg
    C 4589
    NEW
    EZMix Hy-Case SF 100 g
    500 g
    1 kg
    T 2559
    NEW
    EZMix Tryptone 250 g
    1 kg
    Y 1626
    NEW
    EZMix Yeast Extract 250 g
    1 kg
    Expression Solutions:
    Questions and Answers
    Rather than produce a sterile stock solution at the outset, can I add the antifoam to the medium and autoclave it all at once? Yes you can. This can be a convenient method when preparing small aliquots of sterile medium. However, you might also want to keep a sterile stock solution available in case you need to add more antifoam while the culture is growing.
    Are antifoams the same as defoamers, or are we talking about two different things here? Antifoams and defoamers are very similar chemically. The main differences lie in when and how they are used. A defoamer is sprayed or dispersed over an already foamy surface, and should work to eliminate foam quickly, but won't necessarily prevent refoaming after it dissolves. An antifoam is introduced into the foam-prone medium, often before any foam appears, and it should prevent foam from forming as long as it is present in the proper concentration. The concentration at which it's used, though, won't always defoam an already foamy solution — at least not very quickly.
    My fermentation protocols are already well optimized. What kind of risks am I running if I switch to your EZMix media formulations? Frankly, we don't see a down side. We can assure you that the EZMix process provides the same growth characteristics as the untreated powder because we test each new formulation with both E. coli and B. subtilis. We don't release any formulation that fails to deliver at least equal growth rates and maximum ODs when compared to the untreated powder. Sometimes, we actually see slightly better growth with EZMix!
    I have long experience with my old favorites like Terrific Broth and LB broth. Are you sure EZMix versions can offer the same performance that I'm accustomed to? Actually, not the same — better! In developing the EZMix products, we set tighter product specifications. The EZMix formulations can be relied upon to perform at the same high levels, every time, lot after lot.

    EZMix™ is a trademark of Sigma-Aldrich Co.