EMAIL THIS PAGE TO A FRIEND

Caries research

Conventional and anti-erosion fluoride toothpastes: effect on enamel erosion and erosion-abrasion.


PMID 22156703

Abstract

New toothpastes with anti-erosion claims are marketed, but little is known about their effectiveness. This study investigates these products in comparison with various conventional NaF toothpastes and tin-containing products with respect to their erosion protection/abrasion prevention properties. In experiment 1, samples were demineralised (10 days, 6 × 2 min/day; citric acid, pH 2.4), exposed to toothpaste slurries (2 × 2 min/day) and intermittently stored in a mineral salt solution. In experiment 2, samples were additionally brushed for 15 s during the slurry immersion time. Study products were 8 conventional NaF toothpastes (1,400-1,490 ppm F), 4 formulations with anti-erosion claims (2 F toothpastes: NaF + KNO(3) and NaF + hydroxyapatite; and 2 F-free toothpastes: zinc-carbonate-hydroxyapatite, and chitosan) and 2 Sn-containing products (toothpaste: 3,436 ppm Sn, 1,450 ppm F as SnF(2)/NaF; gel: 970 ppm F, 3,030 ppm Sn as SnF(2)). A mouth rinse (500 ppm F as AmF/NaF, 800 ppm Sn as SnCl(2)) was the positive control. Tissue loss was quantified profilometrically. In experiment 1, most NaF toothpastes and 1 F-free formulation reduced tissue loss significantly (between 19 and 42%); the Sn-containing formulations were the most effective (toothpaste and gel 55 and 78% reduction, respectively). In experiment 2, only 4 NaF toothpastes revealed significant effects compared to the F-free control (reduction between 29 and 37%); the F-free special preparations and the Sn toothpaste had no significant effect. The Sn gel (reduction 75%) revealed the best result. Conventional NaF toothpastes reduced the erosive tissue loss, but had limited efficacy regarding the prevention of brushing abrasion. The special formulations were not superior, or were even less effective.

Related Materials

Product #

Image

Description

Molecular Formula

Add to Cart

49143
Mettler-Toledo Calibration substance ME 51143095, Potassium nitrate, traceable to primary standards (LGC)
KNO3
72545
Nitrate ion standard solution, 0.01 M NO3-, for ion-selective electrodes
221295
Potassium nitrate, ACS reagent, ≥99.0%
KNO3
P8394
Potassium nitrate, ReagentPlus®, ≥99.0%
KNO3
31263
Potassium nitrate, puriss. p.a., ACS reagent, reag. ISO, reag. Ph. Eur., ≥99%
KNO3
12648
Potassium nitrate, puriss., meets analytical specification of Ph Eur, BP, USP, FCC, E252, 99.0-100.5%
KNO3
60029
Potassium standard for AAS, ready-to-use, in nitric acid
02762
Tin atomic spectroscopy standard concentrate 1.00 g Sn, 1.00 g/L, for 1L standard solution, analytical standard
SnCl2
204722
Tin(II) chloride, ≥99.99% trace metals basis
Cl2Sn
452335
Tin(II) chloride, anhydrous, powder, ≥99.99% trace metals basis
Cl2Sn
208256
Tin(II) chloride, reagent grade, 98%
Cl2Sn
31669
Tin(II) chloride dihydrate, puriss. p.a., ACS reagent, reag. ISO, reag. Ph. Eur., ≥98%
Cl2Sn · 2H2O
96527
Tin(II) chloride dihydrate, for AAS
Cl2Sn · 2H2O
474762
Tin(II) chloride dihydrate, ≥99.995% trace metals basis
Cl2Sn · 2H2O
431508
Tin(II) chloride dihydrate, ≥99.99% trace metals basis
Cl2Sn · 2H2O
243523
Tin(II) chloride dihydrate, ACS reagent, 98%
Cl2Sn · 2H2O
208035
Tin(II) chloride dihydrate, reagent grade, 98%
Cl2Sn · 2H2O